Last December, I was lucky enough to have the opportunity to travel to Dubai in the United Arab Emirates with my mom, dad, sister, and two brothers. Even though it was one of the few family vacations in which we didn’t step foot in a single museum or attend any historical tours, our trip to the futuristic city on the Arabian peninsula was one of the greatest learning experiences I’ve ever had.

Educational context! Yay!

The United Arab Emirates, (دولة الإمارات العربية المتحدة‎, read as Dawlat al-Imārāt al-‘Arabīyah al-Muttaḥidah)is a country located on the Southeast end of the Arabian peninsula with a population of 9.2 million. (85% of which are expats!) The government of the UAE is a federation of 7 hereditary monarchies, the official language is Arabic, and the official religion is Islam. Dubai (دبي) is the most populous city in the UAE, and has emerged over the past 40 years as a global city and economic hub of the Middle East. (They filmed Fast and Furious 7 there. Obviously very important.)

Screen Shot 2016-02-03 at 11.43.40 PM

Let’s try something…

My brother, Gus, is a photographer. One of his greatest skills is slyly taking photos (and video) of people while they’re not looking and going completely undetected. For this next part of the post, take a look at some of the photos Gus captured on our trip and think about what you see. What comes to mind when you see these images? What stands out to you? Why?

12485931_1058867027498793_4719007540062826304_o

12471606_1058866744165488_1243404800909659400_o

12419287_1058866697498826_7769371129591419379_o

12419054_1058866664165496_1325014097163192541_o

12485899_1058866617498834_7660272044744202057_o

12473734_1058866604165502_8676715231498220392_o

10265495_1058866074165555_5968409642862445919_o (1)

920872_1058865180832311_6839880015043108958_o (1)

12493544_1058865100832319_1119067608292667662_o (1)

12440360_1058864800832349_3057867502846242375_o (1)

12473766_1058864530832376_8847753947518728548_o

12487215_1058864520832377_1786115295344259013_o

Aside from how excellently stealthy these photos are, what was your impression?

I’ll tell you mine.

In these photos, Gus captured what we saw left and right in Dubai: Essentially, just a bunch of people going about their lives. Just a dude sending a text on his iPhone. Just a family buying balloons for their kid. Just a guy chatting up his buddy. Just a dorky dad taking a selfie with a camel. (Seriously, all dads are the same.)

And yet, there’s something shocking about these images. Indeed, something seems… different. And then it hit me.

These photos depict persons in traditional Islamic, Arab, and Middle Eastern clothing doing things I’ve never seen people in that type of clothing doing before.

All around me in Dubai, I saw men and women donning thwabs, keffiyehs, hijabs, niqabs, burqas– and was taken aback by the simpleton-ness of the activities they performed while wearing them. But why? Why was I so surprised to see a man in a thwab pushing his daughter around in a stroller? Why did I stare at the cluster of young 20-somethings giggling and shuffling throughout the mall simply because they wore all black?

As a Westerner living in the Western world, virtually all of the images I see of Middle Eastern Muslims come from the media. So the moment I realized these images stuck out to me as unusual was the moment I realized that the media I was consuming in the United States was not doing an appropriate job of portraying the wholeness of the Islamic identity in the Middle East.

I know that the only reason these images were shocking to me was because they stood out from the images I am accustomed to seeing of people dressed in this way.

The portrayal of traditionally-dressed Muslims in U.S. news and entertainment media (and Western news and entertainment media in general) takes place overwhelmingly within the context of war and violence, breeding fear of Islam in the millions, if not billions, of people who consume these media. Many of the messages generated by this portrayal come from the way we talk about terrorism and extremist acts in the news, such as in the video below.

Indeed, the media successfully reproduce racism not so much because the media audience always blindly adopts the opinions of the media, but rather because the media “strongly suggest how readers should think and talk about ethnic affairs” (Van Dijk 1991, 245).

And Islamophobic messages are not just limited to verbal media– they are also implicit in the images we see on the screen. Anybody who has sat down in front of the TV and flicked on the news, or gone to the movies and seen the latest war action movie knows that the sweeping majority of images we so often see of people wearing traditional Islamic clothing feature extremist terrorists holding AK-47s pointed at US tanks.

This is important because, as one fellow classmate put it at an event on campus I attended on World Hijab Day, “When Muslims choose to wear hijab [or any other form of traditional muslim clothing], they are literally wearing their religion on their sleeve.” So the message the viewer receives is “Arab dress equals Muslim equals Terrorist.”

The message the viewer receives is “Arab dress equals Muslim equals Terrorist.”

12240864_10153279918041167_6720042279157623379_o
via Daily Kos

I would agree with the many people who would argue that for the sake of being historically accurate, certain images of military extremists donning traditional Islamic dress are appropriate. (I’m thinking along the lines of American Sniper…) But as David Miller put it in Promotion and Power in the Media: “There are many different and conflicting ways in which the meaning about the world can be constructed… [therefore, it] matters profoundly what and who gets represented, who and what regularly and routinely gets left out; and how things, people, events, relationships are represented.” Moreover, when people in traditional dress are portrayed ONLY as terrorists, we internalize these messages and subconsciously assume in our daily lives that if  we come across someone dressed this way on the street– or in an airport– then they, too, must be a terrorist.

In COMM 108: Media Processes and Effects, taught by Jeremy Bailenson, my classmates and I learned about Cultivation Theory, one of the groundbreaking Communication theories of the modern era. Founded by George Gerbner in 1976, it states that the constant exposure of mass media messages shape consumers’ beliefs about reality. The research done in support of the theory show that our perceptions of how the world works– how violent the world is, in particular– is massively influenced by the media we consume. So what does a consumer learn about Islam when the only sensory input she receives about the religion is through media that solely focuses on the violent, extremist minority within it?

We’ve got to fix this.

(Hear ye, hear ye, from the belly of the barely-20 college kid who really wants your attention–)

The media must take a more proactive role in consciously balancing out violent images of Muslims with non-violent ones.

Communication scholars agree: The role of the media as sole provider (or primary definer, Hall 1978) is ever the more crucial when selective, biased frameworks are applied to audiences who have little social contact with minority groups (Van Dijk 1991). The media hold an exceedingly powerful position in conveying, explaining and articulating specific discourses that help represent (and misrepresent) groups with whom the majority have little to no contact. 

Therefore, as the primary influencers of consumers’ perceptions of foreign groups, the media have the responsibility to accurately portray these groups by offering balanced imagery that reflects the whole of the group’s identity. In the case of Muslim representation, the Western media need many MANY more images of normal, NON-EXTREMIST Muslims (the 90%) in entertainment and news media, just like the people in Gus’s photographs.

“The problem with stereotypes is not that they are untrue, but that they are incomplete.” – Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

^Noodle on that quote for a while. It’s a good one.

I recognize that it is a rare and privileged opportunity to travel the world. Not everybody will go to Dubai in their lifetime, but everybody will watch a movie or read a news article. Normalizing the appearance of religious, racial, ethnic, and gender diversity is no small task, but the media can do it. They must do it, for they have too much influence in shaping our perceptions of the far reaches of the world to ignore such a great responsibility.

download


Here’s some of Gus’s videography work! He’s a cinematography stud.

Hey! I did a quarter’s worth of research on this topic and wrote a big long paper AND did a long fancy presentation about it in my Program in Writing and Rhetoric class on Cross-Cultural Communication. Here are just a few sources I used in my research, if you want to learn more. Stay curious, folks! -Cath

Miller, David (2002) Promotion and Power. In: The media: an introduction. Longman, London, UK, pp. 1-8. ISBN 0582423465

Saeed, A. (2007), Media, Racism and Islamophobia: The Representation of Islam and Muslims in the Media. Sociology Compass, 1: 443–462. doi: 10.1111/j.1751-9020.2007.00039.x

Seib, Philip, ed. Palgrave Macmillan Series in International Political Communication : New Media and the New Middle East. Gordonsville, VA, USA: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007. ProQuest ebrary. Web. 31 May 2016.

Van Dijk, Teun 1991. Racism and the Press. London: Sage.

Written by Catherine Goetze

Catherine Goetze www.cathincollege.com Find me on social media! Facebook: www.facebook.com/cathincollege Twitter: @catherinegoetze Instagram: @catherinegoetze SnapChat: @catherinegoetze Contact me: cathincollege@gmail.com

13 comments

  1. This is so important and relatable to me Cath! I always had these biases consciously and unconsciously toward Muslims and I am not afraid to admit it. I simply had received an overwhelming amount of a single-sided depiction of Muslims from the media without knowing anything other than where a bomb has went off… I went to France for five weeks during this summer and my host family was kind, welcoming and no different than how families were in North America. It was two days after I realized that host family was Muslim as I saw my host mom walk out with a hijab. This made me realize so much about what you are talking about in this post.
    Great love, Carol Chen

    Like

  2. This is so good. I think years of media stereotypes caused me to feel some sort of irrational fear of the UAE and, specifically Dubai, and this made me realise how dumb that is. 10/10 would read again

    Like

  3. Ayy this is true. Media enforces stereotypes because it’s pretty much the only means of learning about things second-hand! But it’s hard not to overly emphasize the specific aspects that are most important/relevant to the audience, ones that will draw the most attention. (Whether it’s because of money or the fact that media is supposed to give us information on what we need to know, not what there is to know. I mean the 50 pages of Time could be filled with weird details all addressing one issue/person/race, which though paints a more complete picture, would bore the heck outta everyone & Time would be neglecting other issues, and so media would not be fulfilling its initial purpose. Not to mention revenue would suffer) Which is how this bias shit forms. It’s come to the ironic point where what is actually important is presenting those seemingly irrelevant details though, to correct our previously formed biases.

    Like

  4. Under feminist sociology, a researcher named Chandra Mohanty examined how race affected feminism. She found that Western societies created a stereotype for third world women. It shows how Western-ers portray women from different third world countries as having the same issues. We tend to assume that all women from these places have a very similar identity and that they suffer from oppression in the exact same ways, when this couldn’t be further from the truth. For example, using “first world problems” as a term to describe our little issues is wrong because it makes it seem like second and third world countries suffer so much worse and don’t experience the same problems us as. Keep in mind that there are woman who come from royalty in other countries, millionaire business women, and others with a great amount of success. It’s a very ethnocentric perspective because all the media ever portrays and what we’ve been trained to believe is that all women are in extremely poor circumstances, all in the lower class, and face challenges such as abuse by males. While this may not be so far from the truth for some women, this is too generalized to assume for every woman there when clearly, there are still built-in social classes in third world countries. Sure they may not have all of our rights and freedoms, or even our wealth, as citizens of first class nations, but they are not all struggling the same way.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. This is so very important. The study of media and media language and its effect on us has always blown my mind. Thank you for such a good read and message. -Claudia

    Like

  6. Great post, I totally agree on this
    Many of my friends are Muslim so they experience Islamphobia 1st hand which we discuss quite a lot

    Like

  7. Yes, cath!!! Being an American-Muslim, nearly all my time writing about my experiences is devoted to eliminating these stereotypes against my faith and my people, and the fact that you wrote this makes me so happy as I realize that people are finally beginning to understand!! If you want to check out a lil more perspectives here’s something I’ve written: http://thedeansreport.com/item/154-teenagemuslim (also your brother is an amazing photographer!!)

    Like

  8. The media is a business and it will present whatever that generates the most rating.

    And if only 10% are extremists, that’s a A LOT. There are millions of Muslims around the world, 10%?! Even 1% isn’t right. The terrorist attack at San Bernardino happened because the neighbors didn’t want to racially profile the couple, as a result, 14 innocent died. What we need in the country more than anything at this time is more vigilance.

    Like

So, whaddaya think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s